The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan is part of the collection of Fat Daddio’s bakeware and ovenware.
There are some recipes that wouldn’t do well in a regular cake pan; these recipes require sheet cake pans. The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan is ideal for such recipes. Some of these recipes are bar-type cookies, brownies, pastries and sheet cakes.
This sheet cake pan is a highly rated product that is a great addition to any baker whether professional and amateur.
One thing any baker worth his/her salt knows is that the quality of cake pans determines the outcome of any recipe. Getting and using the right cake pans or bakeware is highly important and shouldn’t be taken for granted. Click here to read and get more information about cake pans
That’s why we took out time to research cake pans so that we can help you along as you shop for the right cake pans and bakeware.
This Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan is a product of a reputable brand and comes loaded with many wonderful features. We would discuss these features and their benefits in this review. But before we do that we want you to know a little about the brand behind the product.
Table of Contents
We have discovered something in the course of our researches through the years. This is that brands that have hands on experience in a field always make the best manufacturers of its tools/products. The reason for this is because they understand the workings of that craft and the right tools needed for excellence.
Fat Daddio’s is a brand that was established by bakers and a community of artists and artisans in the confectionery industry. This community comprised of amateurs, professionals and hobbyists.
So with the cumulative experiences of all the players, Fat Daddio’s knows what it takes to get professional results at all times. Not only that, it also knows how to combine commercial grade quality with simplicity of operation and great functionality.
Fat Daddio’s products are designed for both home and commercial kitchens. Professionals and baking enthusiasts alike have learnt to depend on these products for professional results.
All its products are made of top quality materials and designed to produce magical results at high volumes. With these products, you are assured of saving time, money and energy without losing the professional quality of your finished products.
Every pastry tool, bakeware or ancillary products are designed right so that your recipes can turn out right. This Fat Daddio’s Sheet Pan is one of such products.
Features of the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Pan
As we stated earlier, this product comes loaded with many features and they include the following:-
Wide Range of Sizes
The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan comes in a wide range of sizes. With the smallest being 7 x 11 x 2 inches and the biggest 16 x 24 x 3 inches.
These sheet cake pans are the ideal shape for bar-type cookies, brownies, sheet cakes and similar recipes. It is constructed with nice square corners and perfectly vertical sides.
High Quality Material
This Fat Daddio’s pan is made with Anodized Aluminum which is the perfect baking surface. The ‘Safe-Seal’ process of anodizing the pan makes for a stronger and safer pan. It also produces a long lasting and non-reactive surface. This makes the pan compliant with a wider range of recipes that encompasses both citrus based recipes and savory recipes.
Just like every high end cake pan, this sheet cake pan is not dishwasher safe. It recommended to be washed by hand and with mild dishwashing soap or detergent.
The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan doesn’t absorb heat but rather reflects heat. This is one feature of ProSeries cake pans that allow them to reach baking temperatures faster than other baking pans.
Additionally, this pan has even heating ability that allows the recipe to rise as best as possible. Furthermore, once the baked treat is removed from the oven, the pan cools faster than other pans.
This pan is also freezer safe which means that you can freeze/store your baked treat in it.
No Chemical Coatings or Additional Metals
Anodizing is an eco-friendly process of creating a non-stick surface that doesn’t contain any chemical filler PFOA’s, PTFE’s or dyes. It is not a non-stick coating so nothing can peel, flake, rust or transfer into your food item.
Fat Daddio’s sheet pans are sturdily built to commercial standard. They are trusted by home bakers, commercial kitchens and bakeries world wide
In compliance with Fat Daddio’s policy, the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan is covered by a lifetime warranty.
Benefits of the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Pan
With all these features discussed above, you can be sure that users would get a lot of benefits from this product. Some of these benefits include the following:-
The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan can be used for a lot of recipes. The anodized material lends to this versatility. You can use it to make citrus based recipes, savory recipes and all types of cakes without any mishap.
The sturdy and solid construction of this pan assures you of the durability of the pan. It is not one of those flimsy cake pans that warps and rusts with multiple uses. It is a commercial grade product that can withstand multiple uses.
Easy Release of Finished Product
The anodizing process makes the surface of the pan non-stick. All this pan requires is greasing and flouring before use and whatever is made in it would come out easily after baking.
Ease of Use and Cleaning Due to the Non-stick Surface
When your baked treat comes out without sticking on the baking pan, you know cleanup would be a breeze. This also enhances the ease of use of the pan; you do not have to stress to prepare your pan for baking.
With this pan you can say goodbye to frustrating scrubbing and scrapping of food residue from your bakeware.
Food Safe Product
Due to the material and process of construction, this product is non toxic and food safe. It is also rust resistant. You can use with confidence that there’ll be no cross contamination or food poisoning of any sort.
Many Options to Choose From
The wide range of sizes to choose from makes Fat Daddio’s sheet pan a good resource. Pans with the same features are available in sizes for from recipes for two to recipes for family reunions. So avid bakers can now make a small batch of recipe with the right pan size. While commercial bakers have the size for large batches of recipes!
Demerits of the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan
Brand Sticker on Pan is Hard to Remove
The brand sticker on the pan is difficult to remove. Some people do not like to have stickers of any kind on their utensils. So this can prove annoying for such customers.
The edges of the pan are sharp so user has to be careful when handling the pan.
The above demerits do not in any way detract from the performance of the pan as we discovered in the course of our research. You would still get your money’s worth and more from this pan.
We know that there are customers who may not be sold on this item for many reasons. Similarly, this product may not meet the requirements of some others. Whatever your reasons are, we have some alternatives that you can choose from.
All we desire is that you get right bakeware that would suit your baking needs.
But before we go on to present those alternatives to you, there’s one more segment:-
Customer’s Opinion of The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Pan
This sheet cake pan has received hundreds of reviews; most of these reviews are positive while a few are negative. Here, we’ll give you a summary of some of the positive and negative reviews.
Would Buy Again!
This sentiment was echoed by more than two customers who bought and used this pan. These customers bought different sizes of the pans and they were all pleased that their baked treat came out perfectly.
For this reason, they rated the product 5-star and said they’ll buy from the same brand the next time they need baking pans.
A customer was elated that this pan is truly nonstick. She reported that she forgot to grease or spray this pan the first time she used it.
She wrote that the recipe she baked was a really gooey and sticky recipe. But to her surprise and utmost delight, she could serve the dessert without much residue on the pan. In addition the dessert wasn’t messy!
She went ahead to bake another sticky recipe to further test whether this non-stick phenomena was a fluke. This time, the well greased pan turned out the dish without any residue at all.
This customer is so pleased and not only rated the product 5-star but recommends it to every baking enthusiast.
Great Customer Service
A number of customers are pleased with the excellent customer service provided by Fat Daddio’s. They rate this product high not only because of its quality and performance but because of the baking advice and help they receive from the brand.
Worth the Price
Many customers are of the opinion that the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan is really worth the price. They were glad that they added the extra dollars needed to get this pan. Some of this reasons they gave for coming to this conclusion were as follows:-
(i) Durability – They have used the pans for several recipes and on many occasions and it is still performing as advertised.
(ii) Evenly Baked Goods – All their dishes and baked treats bake evenly and looked right.
(iii) High Quality Product – The quality of the material used to make the pan makes it anti rust and anti warping. It is also easy to clean. A customer who mistakenly put hers through the dishwasher was surprised. She reports that although the color changed, it has maintained all its features.
Food Safe and Non Reactive
For many health conscious cooks and bakers, this is a plus with the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan. The fact that they can use this pan for any recipe and it wouldn’t react with the acidity of the recipe is a huge relief.
In addition to this they noticed that the pan doesn’t discolor no matter the recipe it is used for (as far as it is hand washed). They are also pleased that hand washing it doesn’t take much time. All they had to do was soak in warm soapy water for a while after use before gently scrubbing with mild brush and soap.
Stubborn Brand Sticker
As we mentioned earlier, one of the demerits of this product is the brand sticker that’s difficult to remove. Many customers were displeased with it and this cost the product a star or two depending on how pissed the customer was.
However, these customers still testified that the pan performed as advertised. But that they don’t want to have high quality sheet pans with badly scratched stickers.
Dented on Delivery
Another issue that raised negative reviews was the issue of products that were dented on delivery. Customers who had this unfortunate experience were not pleased at all. They felt that such a highly price bakeware should be properly packaged for delivery.
False Advertising By Amazon
One customer was particularly displeased that Amazon advertised the pan as dishwasher safe whereas it isn’t.
She said she discovered this after she had run her pan through the dishwasher. Upon inquiry the manufacturer told her that the pan is not dishwasher safe.
Thankfully, this didn’t damage the pan and she’s still enjoying the performance. However she hopes that this false advertisement would be corrected.
This brings us to the end of our summary of what customers are saying about this product. Before we proceed to review some alternative products, we recommend that you check out some of our previous articles:-
- How To Use A Bundt Pan
- Icing Sugar — The Foundation For Cake Decoration
- Best Food Processor For Dough
- How To Make A Simple Cake At Home
- Best Toaster Oven For Baking
- Cake Pans – The Basics of Baking
Alternatives to the Fat Daddio’s Sheet Pan
Complete Wedding Cake Pan Set
This Wilton Round Cake Pans is a set of 4 top quality aluminum cake pans. These pans are adequate for baking multi-tiered cakes for weddings and other special occasions.
If you are commercial baker that’s just starting out, these pans are a good starter set. With these pans, you have the basic sizes to make standard wedding cakes. You can double the layers of each pan to get higher tiers. These sizes are 6 x 2 inches, 8 x 2 inches, 10 x 2 inches and 12 x 2 inches.
This set also comes loaded with a lot of additional features; the first and best of which is the material of manufacture.
These round cake pans are made with aluminum that’s food safe and has a superior level of even heat distribution. This helps your cake to bake evenly, brown nicely and come out with a smooth surface for ease of decoration.
The quality of the aluminum also makes the pans rust and warp resistant equipping them for commercial grade performance. Additionally, these pans have high solid sides and rolled lips which enable the cake to come out with straight edges.
Furthermore, the Wilton Round Cake Pans are easy to use and wash. All you need to do is to grease the pan before baking. You can also decide to just line with parchment paper. Whatever method you choose, your cake would come out easily and clean. No broken pieces or tough residue to scrub out of the pans!
Unconventional Shape Wedding Cake Pan Set
This Wilton Cake Pan Set is another wonderful wedding cake pan set that’s top notch and commercial grade.
Sometimes, people are just tired of the conventional round wedding cakes and you may want to switch things up.
These hexagon cake pans are what you need. They are designed with heavy gauge aluminum to ensure that they retain their shapes. In addition to this, the heavy gauge aluminum construction also aids even heat distribution.
While it is true that you can bake your cakes in a sheet or square cake pans and then cut to shape, these pans help you eliminate waste. With these pans, you can bake only the quantity of cakes needed because the pan gives you the unique shape desired.
This pan set also comes with all the features of the round wedding cake pan sets discussed above. It would make a great addition to any cake decorator’s collection. What’s more, recipes are included with this set!
Celebrity Brand Cake Pan
Buddy Valestro is the star of the TLC hit series “The Cake Boss”. A celebrity baker and sugar artist of no mean repute, Buddy knows bake and cook ware. He has created a line of bakery and sugarcraft products that would enable you bake like the boss.
The Cake Boss Professional Round Cake Pans is one of such products. This set comprises of 3 round cake pans: 6, 8 and 10 inches respectively.
It is made of folded aluminized steel that’s constructed with wire reinforcement in the rolled rims. The material and design gives the pans durability, stability and strength.
Another useful design feature in the pans is the quilted surface which promotes even heat distribution that makes for beautifully browned baked goods. It also makes the pans resistant to wear and tear thereby enhancing the durability
These pans have nonstick interior which releases cakes and baked goods easily; this also makes cleanup a breeze.
They are oven safe for up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit but not dishwasher safe.
High/Deep Round Cake Pan Set
Sometimes you want to bake multi-tiered cakes with tiers that are over 4 inches without stacking three layers of cakes for each tier. In those moments, you need cake pans that are deeper than the conventional 2 inches deep.
The EURO TINS Round Multilayer Cake Pan Set is one of such sets that you can reach for. It’s a 4-pan set that comprises of 6 inch, 8 inch, 10 inch and 12 inch pans that are all 4 inches deep.
These pans are all handcrafted with straight edges and they are ideal for oven baking.
Although it has no non-stick coating, these pan easily release whatever is baked in them. All you have to do is grease your pans with butter and flour them before using to bake. When done, allow to cool for ten minutes before removing your baked goods.
Due to this easy release feature, cleaning your cake pans after use is no longer a hassle. Additionally, you can rest assured that your pans are food safe as they are void of PFOA and PTFE.
This cake pan set is made with sturdy construction that provides excellent heat distribution that makes for professional looking results. They are oven safe for up to 475°F. You are however advised to preheat oven to 180°C / 350°F / gas 4 before baking.
Before we sign off on this review, let’s give you a quick recap of the products discussed.
Table of Comparison
|Fat Daddio’s Sheet Pan
|Wilton Round Cake Pans
|Wilton Performance Pans Hexagon Cake Pan Set
|Cake Boss Professional Nonstick Round Cake Pan Set
|EURO TINS Round Multilayer Cake Pan Set
|Anodized Aluminum Sheet Cake Pan
|Complete Wedding Cake Pan Set
|Unconventional Shape Wedding Cake Pan Set
|Celebrity Brand Cake Pans
|High/Deep Round Cake Pan Set
No in Set
Items in Set
|9 x 13 x 3 Inch Sheet cake pan ( Also available in different sizes)
|4 Round Cake Pans
|Four hexagonal shaped wedding cake pans
|3 Round cake pans
|6 inch, 8 inch, 10 inch and 12 inch pans that are all 4 inches deep
|High Quality Material, Perfect shape, Temperature Adaptable, No Chemical Coatings (PFOA’s, PTFE’s or dyes) or Additional Metals, Even Heat Distribution(Also heats and cools fast), Commercial Grade and Lifetime Warranty
|Solid aluminum construction, Commercial grade performance, High sturdy sides and rolled edges(lips), Non-stick surface
|Heavy Gauge aluminum construction that helps pan to hold its unique shape for long, All the other features as stated in product 2
|Folded aluminized steel, constructed with wire reinforcement in the rolled rims, quilted surface and nonstick interior
|Handcrafted with straight edges, Non stick coating, void of PFOA and PTFE,sturdy construction
|Easy Release of Finished Product, Ease of Use and Cleaning Due to the Non-stick Surface, Food Safe Product, Many Options to Choose From
|Even Distribution of Heat, Ease of Use and Cleaning, Durability, Food Safe Product, Proper Air Circulation and Risk Free Purchase
|Comfortable to handle, Ease of use and cleaning, Unique shape, uniform heat distribution for evenly baked goods and Durability
|Durability, stability and strength, even heat distribution for uniformly browned baked goods, releases cakes and baked goods easily, cleanup is a breeze
|Ease of use, Easy release of whatever is baked in them, excellent heat distribution, Easy to clean, consistently professional looking cakes and baked goods, adequate for creating high tiers of cake
|Oven safe for up to 475°F, Not dishwasher safe. Preheat oven to 180°C / 350°F / gas 4 before baking
|Heavy Gauge Aluminum
|Aluminized heavy gauge steel
|Ranges from 7 x 11 x 2 inches to 16 x 24 x 3 inches( Available in 25 sizes)
|6 x 2 inches, 8 x 2 inches, 10 x 2 inches and 12 x 2 inches
|6 x 2 in. (15 x 5 cm), 9 x 2 in. (22.9 cm x 5 cm), 12 x 2 in. (30.4 x 5 cm) and 15 x 2 in. (38.1 x 5 cm)
|6,8 and 10 inches in diameter and all 2 inches deep
|Diameters are 6 inches (15.24cm), 8 inches (20.32 cm), 10 inches (25.40cm), 12 inches (30.48cm) – all 4 inches (7.62cm) Deep. Also available are 3 inches and 5 inches deep pans
Now that we have come to the end of this review, we believe you have gotten enough information to make the right purchase.
Always bear in mind that buying premium quality bakeware would spare you a lot of issues in the long run. For that reason, you need to be prepared to pay a little bit higher than you may naturally be inclined to.
Go on now and make that purchase! Do not continue managing worn out or poor quality bakeware.
Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake Pan – FAQs
What Pan Do You Use For A Sheet Cake?
The name already gives us an answer to the kind of pan you use for a sheet cake; you use a sheet pan. It is always best to use a sheet cake pan just like the one we have reviewed to bake any recipe that calls for it. This is because sheet pans are usually shallow and not as deep as other types and shapes of cake or baking pans. So if you bake a sheet cake in any other kind of pan, you wouldn’t get the expected shape and texture.
What Is The Size Of A Full Sheet Cake Pan?
The full size of a sheet cake pan as used by commercial bake shops are either 18 x 26 x 2 or 18 x 24 x 2. That’s just a variation of some 2 inches lengthwise; but the other dimensions are constant. The standard full sheet cake pan is 2 inches high and 18 inches wide.
The Fat Daddio’s Sheet Cake pan that we reviewed is however not a conventional/standard one because it has some sizes that are 3 inches high. This is quite common with many bakeware these days; a lot of them are made 3 inches high as against the conventional 2 inches.
Is A Sheet Pan The Same As A Cookie Sheet?
Although both types of bakeware look similar, a sheet cake pan is not the same as a cookie sheet. Cookie sheets are sometimes called oven trays in some regions while others call them baking sheets.
Sheet pans are bakeware that have rolled edges and are useful not only for baking but also for other recipes and styles of cooking such as roasting.
Cookie sheets on the other hand are best suited for cookies; they are usually designed with flat edges for ease of placing and removing cookies without distorting their shapes. Additionally, they are designed with a kind of lip on the short side to make for ease of handling.
Furthermore, a cookie sheet is not designed for any cooking style other than baking cookie and such like recipes. If for example you use a cookie sheet for roasting, the juices of the food would flow out of the sheet because of its design.
How Do You Get A Sheet Cake Out Of The Pan?
First of all, line your sheet pan with baking paper before pouring in the batter for baking. This is to ensure that your cake comes out easily from a sheet pan without breaking.
Then when your cake is baked, bring it out and leave it in the pan for about 10 minutes or thereabouts.
Then, run a spatula all around the edges of the cake to loosen it from the pan.
Finally, place an oven rack over the sheet pan and overturn it so that the cake pops onto the tray.
Note that there are some recipes that can be served straight from the sheet pan; you might also want to try those out.
Why Is My Baking Sheet Warping?
Your baking sheet is warping because of the high temperature of your oven. Most bakeware show the level of heat they can withstand so when you buy a baking sheet, check the maximum temperature capacity. With that in mind, you would know not to exceed that limit.
Another reason may be that it is too thin or made from low quality materials. That being said however, some bakeware is of good quality do still warp when in the oven but they come back to normal shape when the baking sheet cools.
For some other baking sheets, all you need to do is just tap the pan back into shape.